We don't just make Bagels...

WE LOOOOVE BAGELS.

Visit Half Baked Goods today to try our hand-rolled specialty bagels, pretzels, and bialys. Small batch, big flavour!
PRE-ORDER NOW
 

PRE-ORDER FOR THE HOLIDAYS

View all

DECEMBER 2024

FENWICK MENU

THURS + FRI: 10am - 4pm* + SAT: 11am - *Sold out

Stop by our takeout kitchen at 952 Foss Rd for Sandwiches, Bagels, Bialys, Pretzels and Dawgs. Check our Instagram for updates on stock levels or menu changes.

  • HOLIDAY LEFTOVERS $15

    Stuffing Bagel, Turkey, House Gravy, Cranberry Sauce, Mashed Potato, Greens

  • JERSEY SHORE $15

    Bagel of choice, Locally made Taylor Ham from Fat Rabbit, Folded Egg, American Cheese, Dijonnaise

  • THE REUBEN $15

    Rye Bagel, Slow Cooked Corned Beef Brisket, Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut, House Russian Dressing

  • TUNA MELT* $15

    Bagel of choice, House Poached Albacore Tuna, Kewpie Mayo, Pickled Jalapeno, Scallions, Lemon, Jalapeno Havarti

    *OPEN FACE

  • THE SPINOSA $15

    Bagel of choice, Shaved Steak, Sriracha Mayo, Grilled Onions, Hot Peppers, Havarti, Provolone

  • LOX TARTINE* $15

    Bagel of choice, Garlic Cream Cheese, House Cured Salmon, Pickled Red Onions, Dill, Chives, Lemon

    *OPEN FACE

  • BCLT $11

    Bagel of choice, Lots of Bacon, Lettuce, Heirloom Tomato, Havarti, Garlic Aioli

    Optional: Sub Havarti & Aioli for cream cheese of choice

  • GARLIC STUFFED BAGEL $7

    Plain Bagel, Garlic Cream Cheese, Garlic Butter, Sea Salt

  • BAGEL & SPREAD $5

    What's in stock!

Niagara's Bagel obsession.

Sam makes the best bagels! I've been ordering since around the time she started Half Baked Bagel Co, and I can't imagine my life without them. I even stopped buying bread, I just buy bagels and freeze them for the week.

Heather

This place is basically bagel heaven, prices are basically stealing (never change please). Spreads; dub. Bagels; big dub. SPEADS AND BAGELS; gonna live here forever. Everyone is so nice and welcoming. Should be open 24/7 so I can eat, sleep, and breathe these bagels (and spreads!).

CHLOE

The BEST bagels in the Niagara Region hands down! A wide variety of flavours, awesome customer service and don't forget to grab the cream cheese and whipped butter before you leave.

Jeff

Incredible bagels and incredible customer service!! You can tell that these bagels are hand crafted! Absolutely delicious! Highly recommend!

Jenn

Absolutely fantastic. the service and the food is incredible. the portions are insane! and the cream cheese stuffed bagel was so cheesy, salty and crispy🤤 i wish we could try everything all at once. will absolutely be coming back again and again. grateful to have you guys in niagara.

NICOLE

The best bagels around, so fresh and delicious with so many flavours to choose from. Give them a try, you won’t be disappointed

Kel

The varieties, the flavours and the extras (so many spreads) are worth it every time! So much passion has gone into this company.

Lauren
LEAVE A REVIEW

PRE-ORDER FOR PICK-UP IN FENWICK

View all